Intrinsiqs

Is Nicolet Bankshares, Inc. overvalued?

Nicolet Bankshares, Inc. (NIC) looks overvalued — trading about 25% above its fair value.

Overvalued
Current price $174.08 Fair value $129.99
Price
$174.08
Fair value
$129.99
Current P/E
16.6
Normal P/E
12.4
Market cap
$3.62B
Dividend yield
0.8%
Return on equity
8.8%
Sector
Financial Services

See the full interactive analysis →

Fair value compares NIC's current P/E to its own historical "normal" P/E (FAST Graphs-style). Updated 12 Nov 2026.