Is Selective Insurance Group, Inc. overvalued?

Selective Insurance Group, Inc. (SIGI) looks overvalued — trading about 14% above its fair value.

Overvalued

Price

$102.67

Fair value

$88.52

Current P/E

14.0

Normal P/E

12.1

Market cap

$6.12B

Dividend yield

1.7%

Return on equity

14.3%

Sector

Financial Services

Fair value compares SIGI's current P/E to its own historical "normal" P/E (FAST Graphs-style). Updated 12 Nov 2026.

Related stocks